Are You Defined by Talent or Choices? Here's the Truth Every Leader Should Know

My friend Sarah was gifted from childhood with a breathtaking singing voice. At school, every performance was hers to own, and everyone assumed Sarah was destined for stardom. Talent, after all, had already set her path.

But life rarely follows the script we imagine. Fast forward twenty years, and Sarah leads an accounting firm. Yes, accounting—not the spotlight-filled career everyone expected. At a recent reunion, someone inevitably asked, "Sarah, why didn't you pursue singing professionally? You were naturally gifted!"

Sarah smiled, paused thoughtfully, and replied, "Because, while my talent gave me opportunities, it was my choices that defined who I became."

In leadership, as in life, there's often confusion between our innate talents and the decisions we consciously make. The interplay between these two facets—what we're naturally good at and how we choose to apply those abilities—is crucial yet frequently overlooked.

We are all born with unique gifts and talents. Though our abilities may differ from others, identifying and consciously choosing how best to use them is essential. Making deliberate, intentional decisions about nurturing these talents and consistently growing them each day allows us to maximize their potential and meaningfully contribute to the world around us.

Natural talents are remarkable—they're gifts, intuitive and powerful. Some leaders naturally inspire; others effortlessly solve complex problems. These innate gifts can open doors, granting initial access to opportunities many dream about. But talent alone doesn't build legacy. Talent alone rarely changes the world.

Consider it this way: talent is your starting line, a wonderful advantage. But what transforms potential into greatness are the choices you make along the way.

Take Mike. He was never particularly charismatic or eloquent; public speaking terrified him. Yet, his team considered him an exceptional leader. Curious, I asked Mike how he did it. He responded humbly, "I decided early on that leadership wasn't about speaking. It was about listening and caring enough to act on what I heard."

Mike wasn't naturally gifted with communication, but he chose empathy and attentive listening as his defining traits. Those deliberate choices—made repeatedly, consistently—transformed him from a quiet employee into an influential leader.

John Wooden, legendary basketball coach, encapsulated this beautifully when he said, "Talent is God-given. Be humble. Fame is man-given. Be grateful. Conceit is self-given. Be careful." Wooden's insight is a powerful reminder that talent is only one piece of our life's puzzle. The rest, perhaps the most significant part, is crafted by our decisions.

Think of talent as a toolbox handed to you at birth. Inside are various tools—abilities, inclinations, and instincts. How effectively you use these tools depends entirely on the choices you make. Each decision, each purposeful action, refines your ability, sharpens your skills, and amplifies your impact.

Leaders face this crossroads regularly. Some leaders lean heavily on talent, expecting it to carry them indefinitely. But relying solely on talent is a risky proposition. Without conscious choice, talent can stagnate, leaving potential unrealized.

Conversely, leaders who embrace the responsibility of choice become architects of their influence. They're intentional, aware that the gift of leadership is defined not by the mere possession of talent, but by how purposefully it's wielded.

As Roy T. Bennett, author and inspirational figure, profoundly stated, "Attitude is a choice. Happiness is a choice. Optimism is a choice. Kindness is a choice. Giving is a choice. Respect is a choice. Whatever choice you make makes you. Choose wisely."

This wisdom resonates deeply, particularly within leadership circles. It's a reminder that our greatest legacy isn't dictated by what comes naturally, but by the deliberate, thoughtful choices we make every day.

Consider your own journey. What talents have you relied upon most? Are there choices you've made—or perhaps avoided—that have shaped your current path? Reflecting honestly on these questions can unlock profound insights into your leadership style and its impact.

Ultimately, the contributions we make as leaders don't arise merely from our innate gifts. Rather, they bloom from our willingness to actively engage with those gifts—to choose courage when comfort calls louder, humility when pride tempts stronger, and empathy when detachment seems simpler.

I recall Sarah once saying, "Everyone has something beautiful within them. The magic happens when we actively choose to share it." Indeed, true leaders know that their greatest contributions come not just from that of which they're naturally capable, but from the intentional decisions they make to enrich the lives of those around them.

As you continue your leadership journey, remember this: Talent opens the door, but choices shape your destiny. The leader you become—the legacy you leave—is defined not by the gifts with which you're born but by the life you choose to lead.

Subscribe to my free blog for more insights about leadership, business, finance, personal growth and development, and more.